Oracle’s Sicilia, VA’s Evans do some ‘splainin’ to the Senate VA Committee

Today’s Big Wednesday afternoon before a Senate Committee, sharpening its claws, but no bombshells detonated. As expected, both Oracle CEO Mike Sicilia and VA’s Neil Evans of the Electronic Health Record Modernization (EHRM) Integration Office testified before the Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee. The position that both are taking is simple: the size, scope, timeline, and the product changed. Thus the price increase. 

The Sicilia statement available here is a 12 page summary nearly identical to the House statement [TTA 17 Nov], frontloaded with the successes of the 2026 deployments, the need for the extension, and the path forward that included Oracle retaining some functions that the Cerner scope turned over to the VA. The testimony had a few surprises, including that over the summer, VA and Oracle negotiated the contract and VA reduced the $18.5 billion Oracle request to under $17 billion. Bloomberg Government reported that the negotiations were entirely via email; a VA spokesperson told Becker’s that the ceiling “was negotiated through a series of virtual and in-person meetings.” The FedScoop report also had Sicilia’s live statement updating the interface increase to 190 (versus 164 and the original 57) and that some of the rising costs could be pinned on COVID-19 pandemic-related delays, customizations and “inadequate infrastructure from Cerner that impacted system stability”. 

Carol Harris of the GAO outlined VA’s estimate, sans the underlying analysis which she said that VA has held up for a year. 

  • $37.2 billion is the full lifecycle cost estimate to go live at all 170 sites by 2031
  • An additional $19.3 billion to operate and sustain the system for another decade
  • Total: $56.5 billion.

This contrasts to the Sept. 2 House hearing where VA Deputy Secretary Paul Lawrence estimated about $11 billion for sustainment, for roughly $48 billion total. The difference is $8 billion. Responding to Ms. Harris, committee Chairman Jerry Moran (R-KS) said, “Why do you need an agreement? Just do it.”

Retired (by the voters) lame duck Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) reenacted the Short-Timer Skunk at the Picnic by accusing VA and Oracle of a failed execution and of a four-fold increase in project cost. The reality is that the extension and changes increased the Oracle budget by 1.7x to $27 billion. He used the $37.2 billion lifecycle cost instead.

More tomorrow when Sicilia and Verma (who hasn’t left yet, versus reports over the summer) Face The House. FedScoop

Categories: Latest News and Opinion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *