To paraphrase the underappreciated business genius Desi Arnaz, Mike has some ‘splainin’ to do. Tomorrow (Wednesday 18 Nov) at 4pm ET is the day that Mike Sicilia, Oracle’s CEO, will be facing the US Senate Committee on Veterans’ Affairs. He will be accompanied by Seema Verma, EVP/General Manager of Oracle Health and Life Sciences. The topic? VA Accountability and Transparency: Examining the Current and Future Path of VA’s Electronic Health Record Modernization Program. Also on the hot seats: Neil Evans of VA’s Electronic Health Record Modernization (EHRM) Integration Office and Carol C. Harris, director, Information Technology and Cybersecurity, U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO). Interestingly, the Senate page on the hearings has no agenda nor live link, only a witness list of Messrs. Sicilia and Evans with Ms. Harris.
No rest for the weary, as the parallel full House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs is seeing Mr. Sicilia at 10 am on the following day, Thursday 19 November. The House Committee made no secret of its feelings as he was subpoenaed in a 19-0 vote with a second subpoena for chairman Larry Ellison. Mr. Ellison’s appearance will follow on Thursday 10 December. There is no listing for a Senate hearing at this time.
The House Committee list of witnesses is on a second linked page. Unlike the Senate, there are no VA witnesses, only Mr. Sicilia and Ms. Verma. There is a statement by Mr. Sicilia here that reviews the problems, the resumption of implementations, and why the increase beyond the extension. Stoutly stated is that there has been no repricing the original baseline costs on the original term. Spending is controlled by task order in this Indefinite Delivery Indefinite Quantity contract. On page 7-8, the points made to justify the increase are summarized as “requirements and capabilities that had not been defined, sized, or priced in the original program assumptions”. From the statement:
- VA has increased the number of interfaces from the original contract from 57 to 164 (a 187% increase)
- It expanded the system’s capacity to manage longitudinal veteran health data from 8 million to 26.1 million records (a 226% increase)
- The number of concurrent users increased from 85,000 to 195,000 (a 129% increase).
- The 2018 contract also assumed that VA would take over several recurring functions at defined points, which has not happened.
There is also some finger pointing at Cerner’s specifications for the EHRM contract.
He noted that Oracle has also provided at its own cost:
- Oracle’s new Pharmacy Reimagine 7 module that is anticipated to go live next year
- The advanced interoperability Qualified Health Information Network (QHIN) so that veterans can have strong interoperability when receiving care in the community
- The migration of the EHR from the on-premises data center to Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI) and the associated cybersecurity protections and modern platform that Oracle Cloud provides
- Plus 4,700 configuration changes
It is to be seen whether Mr. Sicilia’s arguments will be convincing or challenging to a rump session of the House which is about to change political party control, with the usual concomitant posturing and preening. Usually, the latter overrides the former. Those with high tolerances can go to the House page to see it livestreamed.
A short backgrounder: Our Readers know from our prior report two months ago that what has made both houses of Congress Madder Than The Wet Hens They Are is that in August, VA tried to slip in a $17 billion increase in budget for Oracle’s EHR development under the cover of a three-year extension to May 2031. The original Cerner (pre-Oracle takeover) estimate was a $10 billion ceiling for a timeline that ended in May 2028. [TTA 17 Sept] Mr. Sicilia’s problem? On 20 July 2022, in his then-role as EVP for Industries, he told the Senate committee that Oracle would absorb any “performance or workflow” issue costs above the original $10 billion ceiling–words that we’d bet he’d wish to retract. What’s worse: Members supposedly found out about the increase via news reports issued in August’s Dog Days [TTA 27 August and 12 August]. On top of that, Oracle blew off a 2 September hearing.
To be reasonable, if you extend a contract for three years, especially given implementation failures at both VA and Oracle, some additional compensation is going to be required and 2018 prices no longer should apply. But the committee members weren’t prepped for the extension nor the increase, and that is both Oracle’s and VA’s unforced error.
Adding to the general agita is the letter sent by The National Association of Veteran Affairs Physicians and Dentists (NAVAPD), a national VA association that represents VA’s 20,000 doctors and dentists, to several House and Senate committees including Veterans Affairs. It recommends that VA halt the entire EHRM rollout until various issues are resolved and goes as far as recommending retaining the venerable VistA, which surprisingly is still running at transitioned medical centers. TTA 5 Nov
Hat tip to a Reader who is familiar with the above matters!







Leave a Reply