Oracle’s Sicilia and Verma meet the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs, do some ‘splainin’, get bashed and some surprises (updated)

The second VA Congressional hearing for Oracle was a sad and barely dignified bash fest. Based on a view of the 2+ hours of the hearing on YouTube, the 25 Members of the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs this morning had no mercy. CEO Mike Sicilia and General Manager of Oracle Health Seema Verma stuck to their story but fumbled their numbers. Faced with a properly critical Republican Chair (Mike Bost) and a Democrat ranking member (Mark Takano) who improperly used his time mostly to bash President Trump’s rich friends such as Larry Ellison, which was not the purpose of the session, one could not be blamed at the outset for not wasting time you’d never get back.

Supposedly this was about Oracle, VA, and the future of the EHRM rollout, including the extension to 2031 and the budget request for an additional $17 million. It was titled “Beyond Go-Live: VA Electronic Health Record Modernization Status Update”. It wasn’t.

This is a selective view, based on viewing most (but not all) of the video, and examining facts as covered previously.

It surely does not help that Mr. Sicilia, with shaved head and wispy moustache/goatee like a dinner theatre version of Superman’s Lex Luthor, got off to a shaky start. He hoarsely read from a prepared statement at the opening. He fluffed his answer to Rep. Brownley (D-CA) who asked him about his 2022 statement about absorbing the cost overrides. He pointed to all the free builds Oracle provided (see TTA 17 Nov, 18 Nov). What he did not do was stick to the solid points of a contract expiring in 2028, an extension, the acquired Cerner EHR failing, and VA’s wider scope for the EHRM as it rolls out. With the same representative, Seema Verma fluffed numbers of the dollar value of what Oracle did absorb, making for a near-perfect ‘gotcha’ for this Member. No wonder Brownley was smiling. The gotchas and the baiting were so evident that at about 1:12, Chairman Bost had to tell Members to not deal with the “personalities of the President” and warning that Members took “the same political contributions”.

Both Sicilia and Verma were weak on financials, a sore point when you are discussing a $17 billion spend increase.

Two physician members wasted time in a side issue, comparing Cerner/Oracle EHR implementation at the Military Health System (MHS) to the VA’s (1:29). VA is far larger (170 hospitals) and requires far more features than MHS’ 51 hospitals plus clinics that deal with active service members with a narrower set of medical needs.  MHS also had a two year head start and largely closed the transition last year. 

Republican Rep. Van Orden was equally savage at 1:33. He scored Oracle on the system failures, “corruption”, lobbying (see below), and paying other companies to sue Epic. He closed with a demand to “sever” Oracle and turn it over to a ‘commercial system,’ namely Epic. Again, neither Sicilia and Verma didn’t have numbers to hand in what predictably was a financial discussion. (See below re Epic)

Verma also denied that Oracle was using veteran data for AI purposes. “We have zero access to the data of the veterans,” Verma said. “We have testified multiple times. We have no access. We do not use that data for any purpose. It is only used by the VA to deliver care for veterans.”

The rest of the Representatives engaged in name calling, fact distortion, and hilarious fiction, such that men like Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller were selfless, do-gooding moguls during their business careers, in contrast to Larry Ellison.

The big surprises are towards the end. Ranking Member Takano finally drilled down to a good solid line of inquiry, one this Editor would ask if I were in his chair.

Surprise #1: He asked asks Mr. Sicilia if Oracle is going to sell or spin off Oracle Health or the EHR business, including whether Oracle has retained investment banks, consultants, and law firms to explore this. The denial was flat: “we have not”. This was then followed by some fumfering as Mr. Sicilia realizes he is speaking about a public company 40% owned by the chairman. Rep. Takano then moved on to the ‘have you ever spoken with…” which was answered by Mr. Sicilia with some verbal ‘iffyness’ but then….

Surprises #2 and #3:  …a flat commitment by Oracle to sustain the EHR implementation through 2031, the point of the extension. Sicilia  also confirmed that Larry Ellison was not involved in VA negotiations, which Rep. Takano tried to negate through Mr. Ellison’s connections with President Trump.

Here is where grandstanding and Blame Game hurts veterans and does not help the goal of an working, interoperable EHR. Ranking Member Takano opened by blaming President Trump for the formal Cerner contract award in 2018 (announced June 2017). For those of us who prefer facts and dates, the timeline says something else over three administrations, Democrat and Republican, from 2015 on. House and Senate staffs would be well advised to look below to brief their Members:

  • The Military Health System (MHS) had awarded its contract to Cerner in 2015, two years earlier. (Obama Administration) In other words, Cerner was an incumbent of sorts. By 2017 MHS GENESIS was underway to transition MHS from AHLTA. Recap of GENESIS, Leidos, and other vendors here.
  • The Cerner contract was worked on and largely agreed to well before Trump took office in January 2017. The Secretary at that time, who lasted a year, was David Shulkin, who was an Obama appointee as Under Secretary in 2015 having previously been the president of Morristown (NJ) Medical Center. He was appointed Secretary and confirmed by the Senate in 2017 under the Trump Administration to head the VA.
  • Trump said nice things about the Cerner award in 2017 and 2018 for good reason. The award came after over a decade of dithering and billions of dollars of wasted effort in attempting to make MHS with AHLTA and VA with VistA interoperable, as well as modernizing VistA [‘Pondering the Squandering’, July 2013]. Your Editor was not only writing about it, but shortly thereafter was employed by Viterion, at that time a VA contractor for remote patient monitoring. Transitioning VA into a modern EHR, bringing over VistA, being interoperable, and training thousands of VA staffers were all major issues we knew about for contract renewal of our independent system that used VistA data.
  • In 2017-18, Trump and Secretary David Shulkin were largely working with Obama-era or early Trump-era appointees at the VA. There were serious failures there as well, such as executive director John Windom who joined as EHRM team lead in 2017 after working on the MHS implementation while in the Navy. He is now Federally indicted on three counts around failing to disclose cash and gifts from vendors, then making false statements to investigators in failing to report those gifts, plus much, much more. [TTA 3 Apr] Dr. Shulkin was another failure; he lasted a little over one year and was dismissed in March 2018 over ethics issues.
  • Implementations started in 2020. VA Mann-Grandstaff blew up while Cerner still was independent, between late 2020 and hearings in July 2021 [TTA 28 July 2021, 18 May 2022]. Oracle’s buy offer was six months in the future from July.
  • It wasn’t till late December 2021, well into the Biden Administration, that Oracle announced their offer to buy Cerner and ‘the transformation of healthcare’. Some of us viewed the buy, right before Christmas, as a pandemic-driven, $23 billion Lump of Coal. But Oracle did not hesitate despite needing extra financing for it.
  • It went through the usual DOJ, FTC, SEC, and EU reviews and closed with little controversy six months later, on 8 June 2022. Oracle already knew the problems, but the closing legally was when Oracle got the keys to Cerner and really started getting into the mystery and misery package they bought. Yes, Cerner was bought by Oracle and ‘Trump friendly’ Larry Ellison. Yet there were no DOJ or FTC impediments to a speedy closing during the Biden Administration. Funny, that.
  • Oracle, of course, is a long time Federal software vendor under multiple administrations. Larry Ellison wanted to aggressively move into healthcare at that time, and as 40% owner it has always been hard to argue with him. One could argue that Cerner wasn’t the best buy though.
  • The building VA EHRM disaster in the Cerner system that started with implementations in late 2020 was on the record and in Congressional hearings for months. It blew up even bigger by July 2022. That was six months after Oracle’s offer to buy but a scant one month after the close. Oracle was aware of it, but both Oracle and VA were concentrating on the five rollouts to date and trying to fix the rolling disaster.
  • The entire rollout was stopped by VA nine months later on 21 April 2023. It didn’t resume till April 2026. It took that long to fix and update the EHR. Those efforts are all on the record between VA and Oracle.

To blame Oracle for Cerner’s and VA’s implementation while Oracle did not own the company (2020-2021)? Then tried to fix a system they didn’t create? Idiotic. Inaccurate. Irresponsible. And tiresome. Beating a dead horse comes to mind. A simple timeline, researchable here and through AI, uncovers apolitical truth. There is enough blame to go around.

Now to today. Did this House session provide a worthwhile update on the EHRM’s progress and clarity on the increase in spending? NO. Most of the discussion centered on rehashing the past failed implementations of 2020-23 and bashing Oracle for asking for more budget for three more years. The $10 million is just about spent. Oracle is getting no more until after May 2028. VA’s role, in the parts I listened to, was carefully avoided. Other than Oracle’s continued commitment, no House member I observed chose to be the voice of reason on the extension, the scope creep, and logic behind the increase. And VA? Absent. Why?

It was far easier for the Members to beat up Oracle on the past, not the future. Oracle was unfairly blamed for Cerner failures that happened before the purchase closed and tried to fix after. They bought into a disaster. Fair, no. Political, yes.

Why does this matter? The House is more important than the Senate is that the House holds the budget purse strings. They can force, if they like, a complete suspension of further EHRM implementations as they did three years ago. If Rep. Van Orden had his way, VA would be forced to terminate Oracle and hire Epic. In fact, Epic has always had a foot in the door with VA from the beginning, with responsibility for the design of the scheduling module awarded at the same time as Cerner had the main contract. LinkedIn That would assume, of course, that Epic would even have the desire to take on the VA and pick up the entire EHRM contract. Strangely, back in 2017, and with MHS in 2015, they were never mentioned. It is well known that Epic, smartly, avoids Pyrrhic battles. 

Oracle, as a long time Federal software vendor, has generously spread its political/lobbying money between both parties. If Mr. Sicilia is to be believed, Larry Ellison has avoided the VA. But retaining lobbying entity Duddington Global Strategies and its founder/principal Brendan Belair this past summer, according to a disclosure filing, isn’t a good look. Mr. Belair worked close to 10 years for VA Secretary Doug Collins while Mr. Collins was still in the House, and most of this time as his chief of staff. Politico

With a change in party control, it serves the Democrats assuming control in January to blow Oracle’s VA EHRM to the proverbial Kingdom Come. Do not be surprised if there is no further EHR rollout in 2028, for political, not operational, reasons.

See also today’s FedScoop.

Hat tip to a Reader who wishes to remain ‘behind the scenes’.

Categories: Latest News and Opinion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *