Theranos update: Holmes, Balwani reprieved on surrender–for now–and Theranos’ creditors try to claw back $25M

March 22, 2023 | by

Both Elizabeth Holmes and Sunny Balwani enter the final stages of legal actions before their respective trips to Club Fed and what used to be called the ‘rock pile’. Between late last week and today, one of Theranos’ late leaders got some additional days, weeks, perhaps a month of freedom, while the other is left hanging until April. Surprisingly, Theranos, the late company, is not actually dead as the proverbial doornail, at least as creditors are concerned–it’s as simple as ABC.

  • Sunny Balwani’s surrender date, set for 2 pm PT Thursday 16 March, was delayed hours before his surrender when lawyers filed an appeal of Judge Davila’s 9 March ruling denying his request to remain free while appealing his conviction. It automatically triggered the stay while the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals considers the appeal. Timing on this is not known.
  • Balwani’s defense also appealed to change the Bureau of Prisons’ ruling sending him to the Atlanta Federal penitentiary. This prison has been dogged by scandals, security lapses, and prisoner abuse allegations. As of now, Balwani’s Federal prison will be Terminal Island near San Pedro, about 30 miles from Los Angeles. Judge Davila’s recommendation was Lompoc in Santa Barbara county, about 250 miles from San Jose. It is not known why the BOP declined the judge’s recommendation, nor why the reassignment to Terminal Island, which once hosted Al Capone. CBS News
  • On Friday, Holmes was in court to delay her 27 April surrender to the Bryan, Texas Federal prison, pending her appeals. Legal observers believe this is unlikely now based on Judge Davila’s decision on Sunny Balwani.
  • Before the court session, a man in the gallery attempted to serve her with a paper demanding repayment of two overdue promissory notes she signed while CEO. The now-disclosed December suit by Theranos ABC, an entity set up by creditors, was filed in Superior Court of California in Santa Clara County. It tagged her with repayment of three notes totaling over $25 million, the first two overdue:

August 2011 in the amount of $9,159,333.65, originally due 2016 and extended by the board for five years, now overdue 
December 2011 in the amount of $7,578,575.52, originally due 2016 and extended by the board for five years, now overdue
December 2013 in the amount of $9,129,991.10, due 2018, extended for five years and due in December

According to the complaint, “Theranos ABC has demanded payment of Promissory Note #1 and Promissory Note #2 from Holmes, but Holmes has failed to pay any amounts on account of Promissory Note.”  CNBC, Guardian

  • This would be in addition to whatever is decided on restitution. As we noted on 9 March, “the prosecution is trying to establish that Holmes’ restitution should be in the vicinity of $878 million, up from an earlier estimate of $804 million. This contrasts with the $381 million that Judge Davila used for sentencing purposes, but under Federal law the guidelines for the latter differ. The prosecution is calculating the full loss of the investors “directly harmed” by Holmes’ criminal conduct.” However, Holmes’ defense is arguing that she actually owes nothing because 1) her crimes didn’t cause the collapse of Theranos and 2) that the prosecution had not shown that the investors “relied on the offense conduct when deciding to invest.” Both this and the appeal will be decided by Judge Davila in early April.   Fox News

Whether Holmes or Balwani will be able to pay even small amounts to the creditors or those who suffered losses due to the Theranos fraud remains doubtful. Holmes is not married to her fiance, Billy Evans, and apparently is being supported by him and her family. Balwani may have some funds, but not $900 million. 

Did Theranos collapse because of Holmes’ criminal conduct? Holmes says no–and no to investors’ claims

March 9, 2023 | by

Restitution–and Holmes’ ability to pay–may be similar to squeezing blood out of the rock at left. In the latest filing from Elizabeth Holmes’ defense, they claim that 1) her crimes didn’t cause the collapse of Theranos and 2) that the prosecution had not shown that the investors “relied on the offense conduct when deciding to invest.” Even Judge Edward Davila of the US District Court had said in a January ruling that 1) was not established by the prosecution.

What the prosecution is trying to establish is that Holmes’ restitution should be in the vicinity of $878 million, up from an earlier estimate of $804 million. This contrasts with the $381 million that Judge Davila used for sentencing purposes, but under Federal law the guidelines for the latter differ. The prosecution is calculating the full loss of the investors “directly harmed” by Holmes’ criminal conduct, which is why (2) is important to the defense.

The next date to watch for is 17 March, where Judge Davila will rule on the restitution. He will evaluate submissions by those defrauded of their investment, with an order then specifying how much goes to which investors in proportion to their loss, covered by whatever she owns and from future earnings. The number on what’s owed may be academic. The defense has already stated that Holmes is, to put it bluntly, broke. In a court filing last month, Holmes said she “has essentially no assets of meaningful value” though she continues to work on patents. 

Holmes and her defense continue to fight to prevent her surrender and remain free until her appeals are exhausted. The second date of note is 27 April–her surrender date to the Federal prison in Bryan, Texas. Sunny Balwani’s surrender date is a month earlier on 15 March to the Federal prison in Lompoc, California. Like Holmes, his defense has filed motions for his freedom through his appeals. Balwani also has prosecutors pressing for restitution around $900 million and likely he has not much left in the way of assets either. [TTA 22 Feb]  Havasu News (from paywalled Mercury News)

Theranos’ Balwani seeks to remain free during appeal, argues he owes nothing in restitution (updated for Holmes appeal)

February 22, 2023 | by

12.9 year Federal sentence set to begin 15 March. On Friday 17 February, Ramesh ‘Sunny’ Balwani, former Theranos president/COO, his defense attorneys, and the prosecution were in Judge Edward Davila’s Federal District courtroom to argue that Balwani should remain free during appeal, and–surprisingly–should owe nothing in restitution to investors.

Balwani is scheduled to report is scheduled to report to the minimum security Federal prison at Lompoc, California to begin his 155-month sentence on 15 March. During the hearing, Judge Davila did not issue a decision on Balwani’s freedom through appeal, nor about restitution. In play are the parallel sentences and appeals of Balwani’s boss and lover, Elizabeth Holmes, with her delay of surrender based on appeals being filed and restitution being decided in the same court.

Balwani’s defense is taking a different tack than Holmes’ defense regarding restitution. His attorney, Amy Walsh, presented that the company was still valuable at the time of Balwani’s dismissal in May 2016. Theranos still had $350 million in cash and intellectual property worth $100 million. Judge Davila seemed skeptical of that:  “Are you saying his conduct was completely divorced from Theranos’ demise?” The prosecution is seeking a far higher restitution–$900 million–than the $120 million Judge Davila estimated at the time of Balwani’s sentencing.

Elizabeth Holmes is also seeking to remain free while appealing her 11.25 year sentence in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, with filings in December and January [TTA 24 Jan, 10 Jan] with Balwani’s filings on a similar timetable. Her defense team also filed for a new trial [TTA 15 Jan] based on purported errors by Judge Davila during her trial. Her restitution hearing on the $121 million Judge Davila has estimated during her sentencing is now scheduled for 17 March. As with Balwani, the prosecution is seeking a far higher restitution–$804 million.

Holmes’ surrender date is scheduled for 27 April to the Federal prison in Bryan, Texas–a change by the Federal Bureau of Prisons from Dublin, California, as rumored in November [TTA 30 Nov]. The women-only minimum security Bryan facility is considered in the Federal system to be ‘heaven’ compared to the Dublin satellite camp, though the latter is only about an hour from her home, partner Billy Evans, and her soon-to-be two children. The selection is important because Federal inmates serve in general 85% of their sentence.

Updated  Holmes’ second child has been born, according to a court filing on Thursday. Her defense continues to press for postponing her surrender during the appeals process. Defense and prosecution continue to wrangle on Holmes’ flight risk, based on the never-taken January 2022 Mexico trip and one-way ticket, now on the basis that she has never directly denied that she intended to flee nor explained her lack of a return ticket [TTA 24 Jan].  Mercury News

Balwani’s defense also maintains that government misconduct during the trial makes success for appeal likely, that he is not a flight risk based on his behavior since 2018, and has no history of violence. The clock is ticking down on both Balwani and Holmes. AP

Theranos Holmes trial updates: did she book a one-way flight to Mexico last year, or were the prosecutors reckless and wrong?

January 24, 2023 | by

The latest skirmish between prosecution and defense. Did Elizabeth Holmes book a flight to Mexico with the intent to flee–or not? According to the prosecution last week, Holmes in December 2021 had booked a one-way ticket to Mexico that was scheduled for the end of January 2022. The departure date was after her conviction in early January that year [TTA 4 Jan 22]. Moreover, the prosecution claims that now revealed fiancé Billy Evans flew not only to Mexico but also to South Africa, and was out of the country for weeks.

The defense in its filing countered that Evans booked the flight in late December 2021 under her name. She had hoped to be acquitted and then free to attend a wedding of close friends in Puerto Vallarta in late January 2022. In the defense filing, “Once the verdict was issued, Ms. Holmes did not intend to make the trip.” She would also be unable, as any trip would require court approval, her passport was expired, and as is customary, in the possession of the District Court.

According to the defense, Evans visited Mexico for four days, returning to California across the Tijuana toll bridge with a credit card receipt. The Cape Town, South Africa flight was weeks later–20 February 2022 departing San Francisco via Newark, returning 4 March via United and in economy class.

Why are the travel plans being made public by the prosecution now? Why is Evans being pulled into it? Holmes has been convicted for a year, sentenced, and is currently appealing. The prosecution knew much earlier about Holmes’ booked-but-untaken flight to Mexico and asked the defense about them via email. When told, prosecutor Jeff Schenk thanked defense lawyer Lance Wade. “I suspected there was an explanation, and I look forward to receiving additional information tomorrow.” The next day from Schenk, “Thank you again for the background information, confirmation, and for addressing this situation quickly. I do not believe there is need for us to discuss this further.” 

The timing is interesting because the prosecution filing objecting to Holmes’ freedom on bail while on appeal had to be filed by 19 January for a hearing by Judge Edward Davila on 17 March [TTA 10 Jan]. Was this one ‘see, see?’ objection? Will there be more? Mercury News

Note: New York Air (737-300 above) is remembered fondly by your Editor as she was this airline’s ad manager for 3 1/2 years in her Life Before Telehealth. It ceased operations in early 1987, merged into Continental Airlines in an ill-starred event called ‘The Big Bang’. (No, we didn’t fly to Mexico — neither will Elizabeth Holmes for the next decade.)

Weekend short takes: Theranos’ Holmes post-prison mental health + more on Shultz and Balwani; global M&A, funding roundup

January 14, 2023 | by

It’s been a bumpy road this second week of the New Year, with the passing away of genius guitarist Jeff Beck, Lisa Marie Presley, and historian Paul Johnson, the unrelenting Harry Hullabaloo, a rain-soaked downer of a JP Morgan healthcare conference, plus a certain 1967 Chevrolet Corvette convertible (Goodwood Green, 327 ci/350 hp) keeping garage company with…classified files.

Elizabeth Holmes’ post-prison future already being planned–and it’s all about her. But not as before. After her 11 years and three months (pending appeal) in (whatever) Federal prison she will be assigned to, her three years of supervised release are being planned for her. In an ‘exclusive’, celebrity website TMZ reports that Holmes will be required to complete a mental health program that she will pay for (details undisclosed). If her probation officer has any reasonable suspicion that she’s violating the terms of her release, her home, office, vehicle, and property will be subject to police search, including DNA collection. No details in the article beyond that. At this point, Holmes should be working with prison consultants (yes, there are such people, and they are not your legal team) in setting her expectations for Club Fed Life, planning her day-to-day in prison, and readying a reentry plan draft that can make her probation a bit easier on all.

In related Theranos news, a soon-to-be published biography of George Shultz, a government supremo during the Nixon and Reagan Administrations, claims that by then aged 90+ emeritus supported Holmes to the point of fixation. In a nearly 20-year tenure at Stanford’s Hoover Institution, respected and honored by all but with no medical expertise, he suddenly became a huge backer of Holmes, helped her get financing through his network of contacts, joined the board, and invited her to family gatherings. Grandson Tyler Shultz, who joined Theranos with his grandfather’s encouragement, became one of several whistleblowers, leading to a family rift never quite mended at the elder’s death at 100. More in the Guardian

Sunny Balwani also filed a motion this week to stay out of prison during his appeal process, arguing he presents no flight or public safety risk. The Law360 article on the 10 January 25-page filing is unfortunately paywalled.

London-based Huma is buying Frankfurt-based Alcedis, a data specialist for clinical trials. Huma will form an advanced clinical trials division with digital solutions across the entire development pipeline, from early stage through to Phase IV hybrid and fully decentralized trials. Terms were not disclosed. Formerly the mysterious Medopad [TTA 28 May 21], Huma seems to have settled into decentralized clinical trials and disease management using wearable tech and apps. Last March, AstraZeneca took a $33 million [£25 million] share in the company, with Huma acquiring their asthma and heart failure patient platform. Release, Crunchbase, Mobihealthnews

In Singapore, Amplify Health is acquiring AiDA Technologies. AiDA has developed machine learning tech to automate underwriting, claims processing, and detect fraud, waste, and abuse. Amplify has similar lines of business plus digital health programs for chronic disease management. Terms were not disclosed. Fintech Singapore. Also covered in the same Mobihealthnews article are:

  • India’s Dozee receiving funding from the UK government’s British International Investment (BII) for India’s MillionICU initiative. The BII investment will be used to convert 6,000 conventional hospital beds in about 140 public hospitals’ ICUs to stepdown beds. The MillionICU initiative’s goal is to convert one million ICU beds. Express Healthcare (India)
  • Taiwan’s largest hospital, Chang Gung Memorial, has adopted TPIsoftware’s SysTalk.Chat for AI-powered text and smart voice-enabled customer service. The Apo voice and text agent assists 80,000 ‘person-times’ per month in patient intake and setting appointments, admissions, and medical information. This saves 50% of time in appointment scheduling via texts or calls that happen within 2~3 minutes.  AsiaOne (PRNewswire release)

Theranos trial updates: Holmes’ freedom on appeal bid opposed; Balwani files appeal to conviction

January 10, 2023 | by

Lost between the holiday and Happy New Year merriment were two year-end court filings by legal teams for Theranos’ Elizabeth Holmes and Ramesh ‘Sunny’ Balwani, who hope to stay free for at least part of 2023.

Elizabeth Holmes: In a joint filing on 30 December, Federal prosecutors and Holmes’ defense requested a hearing by Judge Edward Davila of the District Court on Holmes’ request to remain free on bail until her appeal in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals is resolved. In the filing, the prosecutors agreed to file their objections to her freedom by 19 January. Holmes’ defense had filed her three-page appeal on 3 December with 10 reasons why there should be a new trial. The full legal brief is due on 3 March. Both prosecution and defense had requested that the hearing by Judge Davila take place on 17 March.

Holmes was convicted on four counts of defrauding investors, with her sentence of 11 years and three months taking place on 18 November 2022. She remains free on bail until 27 April, her surrender date. The US Bureau of Prisons has not made public where she will spend her sentence. There is also a question of restitution of $121 million yet to be decided in court. SiliconValley.com

Sunny Balwani: His appeal was filed on 20 December, on the two-week deadline after sentencing, also in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Unlike Holmes, Balwani was convicted on 12 counts, including two counts of patient fraud. The appeal reportedly will be on the grounds of Judge Davila’s rulings and decisions adverse to Balwani during the case. Other possible factors: the weakest counts are the two on patient fraud where testimony and proof were indirect–Balwani had little to do with patients–and that he left in 2016 before the collapse. His sentence was 12.9 years (155 months). Like Holmes, his restitution is yet to be decided. Balwani is currently free on bail, with his surrender date 15 March. No motion to remain free on bail while the appeal is in progress has been disclosed, nor the Federal prison location decision. Yahoo!Finance

For those craving a recap of l’affaire Theranos and perhaps to reflect on it, Yahoo!Finance has produced an hour-long video documentary, ‘Culture of Hype’, on Theranos as a product of Silicon Valley culture. It was produced before their convictions and sentencings. It ends with discussion of how the multiple conflicts between an admittedly naïve founder vision, transparency, and the need to finance said vision in multiple iterations in any startup or early stage company can lead to borderline executive behavior and company collapse. (And yes, your Editor has seen it happen firsthand.) Was Elizabeth Holmes a victim, a sociopath, or something in between? She will have time to contemplate it, as this Editor continues to maintain that her chances of reversing her conviction and going free are as small as that nanotainer she is modeling above.

10 reasons for a new trial? Elizabeth Holmes’ legal team files appeal, delay in prison start (updated)

December 15, 2022 | by

Elizabeth Holmes and her legal team continue their campaign to keep her out of Federal prison. On 2 December, on the deadline from two weeks of sentencing but just made public, her three-page appeal was filed with the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.  She has until 3 March to file legal briefs in the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in California. In addition, her legal team has requested from Judge Edward Davila that she remain free until her appeal is concluded due to not being a flight risk, citing close family ties and pregnancy. Holmes was scheduled to report to Federal prison (still to be determined by the US Bureau of Prisons) on 27 April 2023.

The 10 reasons for a new trial are not fully enumerated in the SiliconValley.com article, but include purported errors by Judge Davila during the trial. These include allowing the jury to hear about regulatory action against Theranos and the company’s voiding of all test results from its Edison lab machines. The filing argues that those events took place after she made any “relevant” statements to investors. Another reason was the sudden visit by former lab director and key prosecution witness Dr. Adam Rosendorff to her home [TTA 26 Oct, 20 Oct]. Dr. Rosendorff reaffirmed in the court hearing that he testified truthfully and honestly, the visit took place during a moment of distress, and that he continued to believe that Holmes needed to pay her debt to society. 

Legal experts mostly agree that Holmes presents little to no flight risk, as she is known everywhere, and is no threat to her community. Where they are split on whether she will remain free during the full process of the appeal, which could be a year or even more. Appeals have low rates of success at the Federal level. To these observers, Judge Davila has been scrupulous–‘bent over backwards’–to be fair to both prosecution and defense during the trial. He has already heard and rejected defense arguments for new trials and acquittals. He did not permit the prosecution to run wild or overcharge either. The decision of another jury on COO Sunny Balwani on all 12 counts, the same as Holmes, also conducted by Judge Davila, may very well factor into an appeal to the judges, unfavorably for the defense. One wild card factor is that the jury convicted her on but four out of 11 counts (acquitting or deadlocking on the rest; Count 9 was dropped due to a prosecution error). The jury for her trial proved 1) difficult to select and 2) difficult to retain, going through three alternates of the five.

Still pending are monetary damages. Updated: checking Judge Davila’s calendar, this will take place after January as his calendar is filled.

It does look like Holmes may enjoy freedom through 2023–but her chances of reversing her conviction and going free are as small as that nanotainer she is modeling. FoxNews, Ars Technica

Theranos’ Balwani gets an unlucky 13 year sentence, restitution to come

December 8, 2022 | by

Today, in the US District Court, Northern District of California, Ramesh ‘Sunny’ Balwani, the former president of Theranos, was sentenced to 155 months, or 12.9 years, in Federal prison. Balwani had been convicted on all 12 counts of fraud and conspiracy, including two for patient fraud, in July. The prosecution had asked for 15 years, as they had with Elizabeth Holmes, who was sentenced by Judge Edward Davila to 11.25 years on four counts. Balwani will be required to surrender on 15 March. None of the coverage indicates that he will appeal. 

The hearing today was about six hours and was far less of a media ‘event’ than Holmes’ hearing. 

Like Holmes, Balwani’s defense requested a sentence of home confinement of four to 10 months, citing that Balwani was an investor ($5 million), was not CEO but COO for six years to May 2016 before the company went out of business, wasn’t involved in key decision-making by Holmes, and gave money to charitable causes. The probation officers’ recommendation was, also like Holmes, nine years. Judge Davila again went with standard sentencing guidelines to produce a result that was far less than most observers, including your Editor, expected given the 12 counts and his direct management of the Theranos lab.

US Attorney Jeff Schenk, who spoke for the prosecution, said “Mr. Balwani knew that Theranos was not generating, and would not generate, any meaningful revenue by being honest with people. So he chose a different path.” The opposite view from his defense attorney, Jeffrey Coopersmith: “Mr. Balwani never wanted anyone to be harmed. He would never harm a fly. Instead, he wanted to give…He’s deserving of a lenient sentence. He’s not Ms. Holmes. He did not pursue fame and fortune.”

However, Balwani was key in making deals and withheld what was really happening in the lab. According to TechCrunch, “During the trial, a Walgreens executive testified that he worked closely with Balwani on the deal. The prosecution also displayed evidence of a text from Balwani to Holmes stating that he deliberately didn’t tell Walgreens that they were using different machines.” He did not testify in his own defense or speak at the hearing on his own behalf.

According to reporter Dorothy Atkins, covering for Law 360, Judge Davila “won’t give Balwani a tougher sentence for leading the conspiracy, but he found Balwani recklessly put patients at risk, since he led the lab.” By his own text to Holmes, “I am responsible for everything at Theranos.” and had, according to the judge, “significant autonomy” in the lab–where the machines did not work. In the judge’s words, as she reported, “Defendant chose to go forward with deception, I’ll call it, and continued to perpetuate the fraud….” After sentencing, his defense requested that he serve in a minimum security prison. At the end, “Balwani packed his things and whispered something to his family members. He didn’t get any hugs, and there were no visible tears in the courtroom.”

On restitution, the prosecution wants Balwani to pay $804 million to defrauded investors, which happened to be the same amount requested bu the prosecution as Holmes. Judge Davila calculated total investor loss as $120 million. A final determination will be made at a later date to be determined.

Balwani is 57, which means that if he serves the typical 85% of his Federal sentence, he will emerge from Club Fed aged 68.  Washington Examiner, NBC, NBC Bay Area, Scott Budman of NBC’s Twitter feed

“Big Story” update: where Elizabeth Holmes will spend 11 years, Cerebral sues former CEO Robertson, Amwell buying Talkspace?

November 30, 2022 | by | 1 Comment

Where will Elizabeth Holmes serve her sentence, whatever it is? A story that got lost in the Thanksgiving shuffle was Bloomberg News’ (paywalled) report that Judge Edward Davila recommended that she be remanded to a minimum security Federal women’s prison in Bryan, Texas, outside of Houston. What has previously been mentioned in the press and by legal commentators is that she would likely serve her time in a northern California minimum security prison about an hour from her present home, the Federal Correctional Institution in Dublin, California. According to commentators, the larger Bryan facility may be better than Dublin, which is a satellite camp. Bryan  “…compared to other places in the prison system, this place is heaven. If you have to go it’s a good place to go,” Alan Ellis, a criminal defense lawyer, told Bloomberg. The final say will be made by the Federal Bureau of Prisons. The selection is important because Federal inmates typically serve a minimum of 85% of their time, unlike time served in state prisons. Gizmodo reports on Bloomberg’s reveal

Holmes’ reporting to prison is scheduled for 27 April 2023. Her appeal to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals must be filed within two weeks of sentencing, which by this Editor’s calendar is 2 December but may be later due to the holiday. Holmes may be permitted to stay out of custody pending appeal if it extends beyond the surrender date if the judge permits. 

Editor’s commentary: One wonders whether Holmes’ appeal will be successful. One factor is what Judge Davila acknowledged: “What is the pathology of fraud? Is it the inability to accept responsibility?” Even in her personal statement during the sentencing, there is evasion. Holmes did admit some sorrow about patients and investors relating to her own failings (back to her again), but sorrow is not responsibility. Moreover, Holmes did not refer to making amends for that sorrow created by the Fraud That Was Theranos. Her defense continues to blame others, like Sunny Balwani, former president and live-in. Even the 130 character letters, many from others who knew her only briefly, blamed others including Balwani, almost tracking to the defense’s talking points. The case proved conspiracy with Balwani, who will likely be sentenced on 7 December for what is expected to be something close to the full 20 years as convicted on all 12 counts.

The tables are turned by Cerebral on co-founder/former CEO Kyle Robertson. Only a week or so ago, Robertson (through his attorneys) reportedly sent a letter to Cerebral management demanding access to documents detailing “possible breaches of fiduciary duty, mismanagement and other violations of law.” [TTA 18 Nov] Now Cerebral is suing Robertson for his default on a $49.8 million loan taken this past January to buy 1.06 million shares of common stock in the company. According to the filing in New York Supreme Court, he is personally liable for $25.4 million, plus interest and attorney’s fees. After his dismissal 18 May, he had six months to repay the loan or direct Cerebral to repurchase or cancel the shares. According to the lawsuit, “Robertson repeatedly asserted that he would not repay the loan.” The troubled company laid off 400 or more in October and is now valued at a fraction of last year’s $4.8 billion valuation.  Stay tuned. HealthcareDive, Mobihealthnews

A cracked SPAC may get itself sold. Talkspace, which has had a year of challenges since its SPAC, apparently is in talks to be acquired by Amwell. According to Calcalist, an Israeli business publication, Amwell is in advanced talks to acquire it for $1.50 per share, or about $200 million. This is quite a comedown from when Talkspace was valued in January 2021 at $1.4 billion. It executed its SPAC in June [TTA 25 June 2021] and hit Nasdaq at $8.90 per share. Today it closed at $0.88, so Amwell’s offer would be close to double. It would also remove another problem. Nasdaq notified Talkspace on 18 November that they were on the verge of delisting their stock, as it was trading for over 30 consecutive business days at under $1.00 per share.

The ‘advanced’ term is interesting because this past June, reports indicated that Talkspace rejected overtures by Amwell and Mindpath. The amount bandied about at that time was $500 million and a sale was expected during the summer. (What a difference six months of economic uncertainty makes.) 

In November 2021, founders Roni and Oren Frank stepped down and their COO resigned shortly thereafter on a conduct-related allegation. Shareholders started to sue starting then. YTD results have also been dismal, with losses of $61 million on revenues of $89 million.

Talkspace would bolster Amwell’s mental health capabilities in telepsychiatry with a DTC and enterprise product. If the company hung on to most of their $184 million in cash reported in June (of the SPAC’s $250 million), for Amwell it also would be a deal that almost pays for itself. HealthcareDive, FierceHealthcare

Breaking–The Theranos denouement: Elizabeth Holmes sentenced to 11.25 years with an investor loss of ~$121 million

November 18, 2022 | by

Elizabeth Holmes received her sentence today by Judge Edward Davila of the US District Court of Northern California, in an over four-hour court proceeding.

The sentencing was based on Federal guidelines for four counts of a Class C (non-violent) felony, as well as the recommendations of probation officers. Your Editor watched this in real time from the NBC Bay Area feed and reporter Scott Budman’s Twitter feed from the courtroom (cameras are excluded). This started at 10am PT with last arguments made by prosecution and defense and victim statements. The actual reading of the sentence in his summation by Judge Davila took a little more than 20 minutes, delivered in a silent courtroom, concluding after 2pm PT.

The decision:

  • Prison sentence: 11.25 years (11 years, three months), to be followed by three years of supervised release. Holmes will be required to self-surrender on 27 April 2023. This is likely after her delivery date. This was less than the 15 years requested by the prosecution (in turn less than the 20 years maximum), more than the nine years recommended to the judge by the probation officers (what is called a downward deviation), but entirely based on the sentencing manual. Judge Davila obviously did not believe that he could justify that downward deviation.
  • The investor loss. Judge Davila estimated the total loss by 10 investors at $384 million, not $804 million. A ‘reasonable total loss’ is only $121 million. This winnowing down is a big win for Holmes. While she will never be able to pay it, below $500 million it takes down her possible sentencing, according to NBC’s legal commentator, former prosecutor Dean Johnson. The total and final amount will be settled at a later date at a restitution hearing.

Scott Budman’s tweets included the jousting between both prosecution and defense on multiple points.

There were victim impact statements directed to Holmes, which include the father of whistleblower Tyler Shultz, Alex Shultz, whose grandfather was investor, board member, and enabler George Shultz. “There’s a lot of talk about Sunny and Elizabeth. From my family’s perspective, Elizabeth is their Sunny Balwani. She took advantage of my family.” Theranos lawyers burst into their home (average for the bare-knucks tactics of one David Boies) with no chance for Tyler to defend himself. It also pitted the senior generation (now departed) versus son and grandson, ripping apart the family.

A cancer patient testified; the judge gently said he read her letter.

Holmes presented her own statement as the last word. “I am devastated by my failings. I have felt deep pain for what people went through, because I failed them. To investors, patients, I am sorry.”

Judge Davila’s formal sentencing of Holmes was well under 30 minutes. A judge’s summation must primarily justify the sentencing. It is where he speaks at length. It must detail his logic, discretion, reasoning, and thought process based on the information presented at trial and by precedent. The quotes are from Scott Budman’s play-by-play tweets:

“This case is troubling on so many levels. What went wrong? This is sad because Ms. Holmes is brilliant.”
“Failure is normal. But failure by fraud is not OK.”
“We know by the texts with Mr. Balwani that there was conspiracy.”
“What is the pathology of fraud? Is it the inability to accept responsibility? Perhaps that [is] the cautionary tale to come from this case.”

This Editor will reflect on this, with more information, next week. Will there be a genuine Silicon Valley impact in the middle of a downturn or has this all been factored in? There is the implosion of bitcoin/crypto FTX in the headlines–2022’s equivalent of the early 1930s’ fall of Swedish Match/Ivar Krueger and Ivan Boesky’s stock fraud of the Big ’80s.

Certainly there will be appeals by the defense and by the Feds. A defense appeal, for instance, may lengthen the time before she will serve her sentence.

Sunny Balwani’s attorneys will not be having a Palm Springs Weekend, either, now knowing the thought process of Judge Davila. 

With deep appreciation to the NBC Bay Area team coverage, the analysis by Dean Johnson, and warmly to Scott Budman.

The Theranos denouement: ‘Humble, hardworking’ Elizabeth Holmes sentencing Friday; prosecution and defense paint different pictures (updated)

November 17, 2022 | by

Elizabeth Holmes finally faces the music and perhaps the mercy of Judge Edward Davila on Friday, 10 am PT. Convicted on four felony counts of 11 and defrauding investors of over $144 million, the prosecution has called for Holmes to go to Federal prison for 15 years of the maximum 20, plus three years of supervised release. Restitution of $804 million would go to investors plus a fine of $250,000 for each charge. In US Attorney Stephanie Hinds’ 46-page pre-sentencing memo to Judge Davila, the prosecution states that she was blinded by ambition. “She repeatedly chose lies, hype and the prospect of billions of dollars over patient safety and fair dealing with investors. Elizabeth Holmes’ crimes were not failing, they were lying—lying in the most serious context, where everyone needed her to tell the truth.” They called her crimes “extraordinarily serious, among the most substantial white collar offenses Silicon Valley or any other district has seen.” and that her actions damaged the trust and integrity that is needed for Silicon Valley investors to trust companies to fund ideas before profits are seen. The cut: “She stands before the Court remorseless. She accepts no responsibility. Quite the opposite, she insists she is the victim.”

In all fairness, her defense has relentlessly painted Holmes as exactly that, from young, naive, battered, psychologically and sexually abused Trilby to Sunny Balwani’s Svengali. Their argument in their 82-page sentencing memo argues for mitigation to the point of no sentence at all, or a minimal sentence of no more than 18 months in home confinement plus her continuing service work. Supporting her character as a ‘humble, hardworking, and compassionate woman who deeply wants to give what she can to the world” and not motivated by greed or personal gain were character testimony letters from Billy Evans, her partner, as one would expect, but also from some unexpected places: the Senator from this Editor’s home state of New Jersey, Cory Booker, who knew her starting in 2012, and a former EPA head, William Reilly, who worked with Holmes’s father back in the George H.W. Bush administration. Their memo cited 130 letters.

Also revealed by the defense: Holmes is not only the mother of a year-old son but also pregnant. Evans’ letter contains another heartbreaking fact. Her beloved ‘wolf’ of a husky dog, Balto, was tragically killed by a mountain lion while she and Evans were living in seclusion in a rural area. While they lived in San Francisco, according to him, they were harassed by reporters, ordinary people, and threatening letters, so they hit the road for at least 6 months living in a camper.

Holmes’ ability to pay $804 million to the likes of Safeway and Walgreens seems to be a bit of a reach, as Holmes never cashed out of Theranos stock–at its peak valued at  $4.5 billion–is unemployed with no prospects, and is widely assumed to be, as they say, flat broke as are her parents. As to her sentence, what is widely expected is a multi-year sentence. If that happens, the defense will request that she remains free on bail (a motion for stay) while the filing to the Federal Appeals Court is made, a process that can take a year or more from filing to a decision. 

Judge Davila’s record has been to take in all the circumstances and to be measured in sentencing. After several years, he is intimately familiar with Theranos to the likely point of dreaming about it at night. Factors he may consider in sentencing, start of her term, where it will be served, restitution and fines: lack of flight risk, Holmes’ young child, and her current condition both physical and financial. Savvy court watchers have noted that if Federal law enforcement is in the courtroom, Holmes may initially be taken to prison and held, then freed on bail pending appeal. The jury convicted her on only four out of 11 counts (and threw out the 12th), but it remains that the prosecution proved and the jury decided that she was fully capable of engineering fraud, not once but several times, leaving Balwani’s Mesmerizing Influences aside.

Balwani’s own sentencing on 12 charges, with the same maximum of 20 years in Federal prison, is scheduled for 7 December, Pearl Harbor Day, at 10 am PT.

The Mercury News articles, while thorough, are paywalled: 11 November (defense memo), 11 November (Billy Evans letter), 14 November (prosecution filing). FierceBiotech, MedCityNews

The US Attorney, Northern District of California summary: U.S. v. Elizabeth Holmes, et al.  District Court documents here.

NBC Bay Area will cover the sentencing live here at 10 am PT, 1 pm ET, 6 pm GMT.

News updates: Theranos’ Holmes goes ‘mental’ in last ditch defense; troubled Cerebral telemental health fires another 400

October 26, 2022 | by

Blood out of a rock? The Holmes’ defense goes ‘mental’ with Dr. Adam Rosendorff. Reduced to a limited hearing before Judge Edward Davila and the US District Court in San Jose, where Rosendorff not only reaffirmed his testimony but also explained the circumstances around his visit to the home, the Holmes defense filed a motion on Monday, citing an obscure interview published in September by the South African Jewish Report to cast doubt about the veracity and credibility of his testimony. Rosendorff, who was born in South Africa, recounted to the interviewer that the stress from blowing the whistle on Theranos led to a “breakdown, medication, hospitalization, and health problems.”

Rosendorff also stated in the interview that by the time the trials (Holmes and Balwani) were scheduled in early 2020, he was off medication. The trials finally took place in 2021 (Holmes) and this year. When questioned last week by defense lawyer Lance Wade about his mental state, his response was that “I’m finding this line of questioning to be invasive.” and that his “mental state was solid” when he drove to Holmes’ home wanting to speak with her. The prosecution objected to the questioning and Judge Davila upheld it.

The prosecution’s response to the defense filing is that the court record “contains no indication whatsoever that Dr. Rosendorff suffered from a mental health issue that affected his ability to serve as a reliable witness,” and that “newly raised and uncorroborated insinuations about Dr. Rosendorff’s mental health do not justify discounting his testimony or granting a new trial.”

The Mercury News’ money quote from New York defense lawyer Jennifer Kennedy Park: “I think the judge already made the decision that this is not relevant.” Another lawyer quoted, former Santa Clara County prosecutor Steven Clark, said that the stress can be difficult but that it apparently didn’t affect Rosendorff’s capacity to testify–and that he was consistent across two trials.

Unless Judge Davila decides to delay–not likely given the above and the pending sentencing for both Holmes and Balwani–or there are additional magic ‘rabbits out of hats’, Holmes’ sentencing remains scheduled for 18 November, Balwani’s later this year.

And speaking of mental health, beleaguered telemental health provider Cerebral let go of 400 more staff, or another 20% of their remaining workforce. This follows a layoff of ‘hundreds’ of contractors, including nurse practitioners who did counseling and support staff, at end of May. Cerebral is ‘restructuring’ under a new CEO, David Mou, who replaced CEO and co-founder Kyle Robertson  forced out by the Cerebral board after the first round of investigations by the Department of Justice (DOJ) on over-prescribing of controlled substances and the subsequent defection of CVS Health and Walmart, as well as Truepill on mail fulfillment. Their statement cites “operational efficiencies while prioritizing clinical quality and safety across the organization.” Cerebral had at its peak in the spring 4,500 employees.

In addition to the DOJ investigation, the FTC is investigating Cerebral for deceptive advertising [TTA 1 June] and a former VP of product and engineering, Matthew Truebe, is suing for wrongful dismissal, further exposing the inner workings of the company [TTA 16 June]. Employees have gone public with tales of pushing prescriptions to 95% of patients, disregarding state regulations, and generally Running Wild over any semblance of clinical probity [TTA 29 June]. Certainly Softbank cannot be delighted at the rolling crackup of their once-valued $4.8 billion baby for which they’ve led funding of over $426 million. TechCrunch, Healthcare Dive.

Rosendorff stands pat on Theranos’ Elizabeth Holmes: “She needs to pay her debt to society”

October 20, 2022 | by

Monday’s limited hearing in US District Court on Adam Rosendorff’s Mysterious Visit to Casa Holmes is likely to be a Defense Dud. Rosendorff walked Judge Edward Davila through the circumstances of his visit, what he said–which differed from Holmes’ partner Billy Evans’ recollection–and reaffirmed his testimony in the Holmes trial plus his sworn declaration given prior to the hearing.

  • He recounted his feelings of distress that Holmes’ and Evans’ son would “spend his formative years” without his mother in prison. The surprise contained here is his testimony that “It’s my understanding that Ms. Holmes may be pregnant again.” Follow-up by reporters outside of court was not answered by either Dr. Rosendorff or Evans.
  • Rosendorff reaffirmed that he testified “truthfully and honestly” on Theranos. “At all times the government has encouraged me to tell the truth and nothing but the truth.” 
  • Regarding telling Evans that the prosecution made the situation at Theranos sound worse than it was, Rosendorff did not recall that. He reconfirmed that he didn’t believe the prosecution did that. Rather, the prosecution “was trying to paint an accurate picture of Elizabeth Holmes.” 
  • As to another Evans statement that Rosendorff regretted that the prosecutors made people at Theranos look bad, he countered that “to the extent that other people looked bad, it was because of their association with Elizabeth.”
  • Overall, “I don’t want to help Ms. Holmes. At this point she needs to pay her debt to society.”

For anyone who has been through a legal process, Dr. Rosendorff’s all-too-human reactions after the extraordinary strain of two trials as well as the destruction of his career, his wanting to square things with, and confront, the cause of years of tsuris is understandable. That, of course, was ill-advised in the extreme. One only hopes that he has family and friends to comfort, counsel, and help him in moving toward a satisfying future, perhaps well away from California. He can also reflect that the four counts for Holmes and 12 for Balwani were on fraud, proved by the testimony of others who certainly aren’t running to Casa Holmes banging on her door.

Barring any other defense rabbits out of hats, Holmes is scheduled to be sentenced by Judge Davila on her four counts on 18 November to begin paying her debt to society. Mercury News

Theranos’ Holmes sentencing now 18 November, defense wants to expand hearing scope; Balwani can’t join in

October 13, 2022 | by

Elizabeth Holmes will be receiving a limited hearing concerning The Mysterious Visit of Dr. Adam Rosendorff and her defense is attempting to expand the hearing. But Sunny Balwani won’t be joining in. The highlights of their recent District Court activities under Judge Edward Davila:

  • Holmes’ sentencing on her four counts has been reset to 18 November at 10am PT. This is despite the limited hearing on 17 October to determine whether Adam Rosendorff was really regretful about his testimony (as the Holmes defense maintains) and what he said and did. 
  • In a separate order, Judge Davila rejected Balwani’s defense move to join in the hearing. Rosendorff’s statements to Evans “related exclusively to his testimony during Ms. Holmes’ trial, not Mr. Balwani’s trial,” and provide “no basis for Mr. Balwani to examine” Rosendorff at the hearing.
  • In a filing, Rosendorff’s legal team asked Judge Davila to quash a subpoena sent by Holmes’ defense to obtain additional information from Rosendorff to use in next week’s hearing. “(Holmes) has sought to transform that limited inquiry into a free-for-all in which Dr. Rosendorff would be required to search through more than a year’s worth of sensitive emails, text messages, and other communications with family, friends, and others so that (Holmes) can try, yet again, to make him look like a liar.”
  • In that filing, the legal team also provided explanations of Dr. Rosendorff’s actions on that day. Driving around the area, he saw that the Theranos building had been torn down and a residential development complex built in its place, and the Palo Alto Walgreens where the first pilot took place had been replaced by a rug store. He wanted to “forgive her for the pain and suffering her actions have caused in his life” and to express his condolences on the child growing up without a mother. Unfortunately, he didn’t stop there on Memory Lane but took a drive up to the well-known location of her rental house, where recollections do differ and increased his tsuris as a result. 

Mercury News, Palo Alto Online

Catchup News Roundup: UHG-Change buy final; Theranos’ Holmes sentencing delayed, ‘limited hearing’ agreed to

October 4, 2022 | by

Note: your Editor is on the mend after returning from vacation with a nasty bug that’s laid her low for the better part of a week.

UnitedHealth Group’s Optum unit completed its acquisition of Change Healthcare, after the 10-day agreed waiting period post-decision. As planned, Change will be folded into the OptumInsight unit. The all-cash deal was either $7.8 billion or $13 billion, depending on what source you go with [TTA 20 Sept].

The Department of Justice has a generous quantity of Grade A, Extra Large Egg on its metaphorical face. The District Court decision found that the DOJ did not conclusively prove its allegations of antitrust and loss of competition in services. Statements from UHG’s competitors such as Cigna, Aetna, and Elevance (Anthem) that the acquisition would not lead them to ‘stifle innovation’ also weakened the DOJ’s case. The major conflict, ClaimsXtend, was already in progress of divestiture to TPG.

Challenging acquisitions post-closing is difficult but has happened. Readers may recall the 2019 nine-month long District Court Tunney Act review drama over the final approval of the CVS buy of Aetna, dragging on long after the buy was final and reorganization was underway. If the Tunney Act applies, and this goes to a certain Judge Richard Leon, watch out!  Optum’s release did not disclose reorganization plans or management changes. Healthcare Dive, FierceHealthcare 

Elizabeth Holmes’ sentencing delayed to allow a ‘limited hearing’ on The Mysterious Visit of Adam Rosendorff.  The ‘crafty strategy’ [TTA 16 Sept] scored a win today (3 October). Judge Edward Davila accepted the defense’s request for a limited hearing on whether there was any prosecutorial misconduct in Dr. Rosendorff’s testimony and delayed Holmes’ sentencing originally scheduled for 17 October.

In August, according to Holmes’ partner Billy Evans, in a scene lifted out of TV’s Perry Mason, Dr. Rosendorff arrived at Holmes’ home doorstep disheveled and apologetic, allegedly telling Evans that the prosecution “made things sound worse than they were.” Yet Dr. Rosendorff swore a declaration to the prosecution after the Mysterious Visit that he testified “completely, accurately and truthfully” and stood by his testimony, while expressing “compassion” for her and her family. Rosendorff’s testimony was more about the Theranos labs and how they defrauded patients based on specious PR and inflated claims, not the investor fraud of which she was convicted. 

The limited hearing has been scheduled for 17 October (the original sentencing date). Judge Davila has already stated that the hearing will not last the full day. He also offered to both the prosecution and defense options for new sentencing dates: mid-November, early December, or mid-January. How this will affect Sunny Balwani’s upcoming sentencing on 12 counts is not known. Mercury News 

Elizabeth Holmes’ three swings and a miss in overturning her trial verdict reveal a crafty strategy

September 16, 2022 | by

Putting off the inevitable? Elizabeth Holmes’ legal team in the past two weeks has filed a flurry of motions in US District Court to have her verdict thrown out prior to sentencing on Monday 17 October.

  • The filing on 1 September sought to have the verdict of guilty on four counts [TTA 4 Jan] tossed with no new trial. This was denied in a preliminary ruling by Judge Edward Davila, stating that the verdict by the jury was supported by the evidence. A final ruling is pending arguments by the defense and prosecution.
  • The three filings on Tuesday 6 and Wednesday 7 September seek to have Judge Davila rule, on the basis of new evidence, for a new trial.

According to the Mercury News, the first motion on Wednesday, which states that arguments presented in the Sunny Balwani trial could have acquitted her, has little chance of being successful and in fact may be counterproductive in annoying the judge in that case–also Judge Davila. The second motion filed has a better shot, including on appeal. It centers on the “Brady rule” that requires prosecutors to disclose and turn over information that could be helpful to the defense. This was the database of patient test results that the prosecution failed to preserve. It didn’t factor in the trial, but could in the expected appeal. 

The filing on Tuesday is straight out of an episode of Perry Mason. Holmes’ partner (and father of her one-year old son) Billy Evans declared that former Theranos lab director Dr. Adam Rosendorff showed up at the door of her home in a ‘desperate and disheveled’ state. In the declaration, Evans stated that “He said he wants to help her. He said he feels guilty. He said he felt like he had done something wrong. He tried to answer the questions honestly but that the prosecutors tried to make everybody (in the company) look bad” and that prosecutors “made things sound worse than they were.” Legal experts interviewed by the Mercury News believe it’s not the remorse, but the pressure prosecutors may have put on the witness. A hearing on this would be extensive and involve both prosecution and defense. Of course, this neglects that during the trial, the defense attempted to rip apart Dr. Rosendorff’s testimony as self-serving and essentially incompetent.

Net-net, Elizabeth Holmes has a best-money-can-buy legal strategy designed to delay her serving time, if not negate it, on the four of 12 counts on which she was convicted.  Mercury News 1 Sept, Mercury News 10 Sept  Adam Rosendorff’s testimony during trial summarized in Chapters 1 and 2